Former Guam Archbishop Anthony Apuron

Exact Vatican Tribunal Charges Against Guam Archbishop Unknown

Even I was guilty of assuming that Archdiocese of Agaña (Guam) Archbishop Anthony Apuron was charged with child sexual abuse in his current and highly publicized Vatican Tribunal.

But then I learned:

Charges in a Vatican Tribunal are secret.

Apuron’s replacement confirmed it.

From The Tablet (UK):

Asked if [Guam] archbishop [Anthony Apuron] was also being charged for financial mismanagement, not just alleged child abuse, Archbishop Byrnes told reporters he did not know what the charges ended up being, but that they would be published eventually after the Vatican judges deliberated. (emphasis mine)

Guam’s Catholics and the public are under the assumption that Apuron’s Vatican trial is for child sexual abuse. The Vatican and Apuron’s lawyers, I believe, are taking that assumption and running with it.

Byrnes admitted that he has no idea what the charges against Apuron are. He is the highest ranking cleric in the Archdiocese of Agaña, Guam. He was the man hand-picked to replace Apuron.


Coadjutor Archbishop Michael Byrnes. He doesn’t know what the charges are, either.

What about the victim depositions?

Although Apuron’s alleged victims have been deposed (without their legal counsel, of course, and under the “Pontifical Secret”), they could be supplementary witnesses in the other possible charges against Apuron. Remember, he has been accused of everything from financial mismanagement to “widespread disarray of church operations.”

If we don’t know what the charges are, how can we even be assured of the outcome?

2 thoughts on “Exact Vatican Tribunal Charges Against Guam Archbishop Unknown

  1. You have to understand how the church and Vatican operate:
    the charges are secret, the process is secret and the outcome is secret.
    There are no checks and balances and no quality assurance. We just have to trust that they will do the right thing. Whoever ‘they’ are?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *